Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026
Crime & Courts

Gangsters whose plot failed after hitman got “cold feet” lose appeal bid

David Nisbet and Declan McCuish, jailed for 13 and 11 years over a £70,000 plot to kill Ryan Carvill in Glasgow, have had their sentence appeals refused. Liverpool hitman James Richards pulled out at the last minute.

MD
Megan Doyle
2 min read
Ryan Carvill, the target of the failed murder plot
Manchester Evening News

A court has refused a bid to reduce the prison sentences of two Scottish gangsters who conspired with a Liverpool hitman to murder a “grass”. David Nisbet, 36, and Declan McCuish were jailed last year for their 2020 plot to kill Ryan Carvill in Glasgow. They were sentenced to 13 and 11 years respectively.

What Was the Plot?

The men agreed with would-be hitman James Richards, from Liverpool, that he would be paid £70,000 for the hit. EncroChat messages from April 2020 showed Nisbet suggested three potential hitmen before an agreement was reached with Richards. He was collected from Liverpool, taken up to Scotland, given a gun on 11 April and shown places where Carvill was likely to be that day. McCuish was in charge of securing a hideout for him.

Prosecutor Lindsey Dalziel said Nisbet “called the shots” and the gang “sought to turn the streets of Glasgow into a warzone” in a bid to catch their target.

Why Did It Fail?

Richards did not go through with it. He got “cold feet” and raised concerns about the getaway car, and the messages showed he asked for a faster car or a motorbike. He returned to Liverpool on 13 April, but police stopped his car on the M74. Nothing of note was found, but analysis of EncroChat, the encrypted phone network hacked by European law enforcement, later revealed how deeply he was involved.

Richards was arrested in June 2021 but released under investigation. He then fled to Spain and stayed there until he was extradited in January 2026. He was sentenced to seven years and six months. Another gang member, Anthony Connell, was jailed for six years and nine months. Carvill, who moved between Glasgow and Dubai, was himself jailed for his role in a drug supply operation.

Nisbet and McCuish both denied conspiring to murder Carvill but were found guilty of an offence carried out at addresses in Glasgow, East Dunbartonshire and Liverpool.

What Did the Appeal Court Say?

At a hearing last month, Nisbet, who did not have a lawyer, told judges Lord Beckett, Lord Matthews and Lord Ericht that people convicted of similar offences had received shorter terms. He asked for his sentence to be reduced “in the interests of justice”. McCuish’s lawyer argued the sentence was too harsh given his lesser role compared with the other conspirators.

In a written judgement, Lord Beckett said: “We are not persuaded that it was an excessive sentence, there was no miscarriage of justice.” Both appeals were refused.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why were David Nisbet and Declan McCuish jailed?
They were sentenced to 13 and 11 years respectively for conspiring to murder Ryan Carvill in Glasgow in 2020, in a plot involving a Liverpool hitman who was offered £70,000.
Why did the murder plot fail?
Hitman James Richards got “cold feet” and raised concerns about the getaway car before pulling out. Police later stopped his car on the M74 as he returned to Liverpool.
How were the conspirators caught?
Messages on the encrypted EncroChat phone network, which had been hacked by European law enforcement, revealed the scope of the murder conspiracy.