Young people may lose benefits under Milburn review as Pat McFadden calls for “complete reset”
Alan Milburn’s review of young people not in work or education is due on Tuesday and is expected to propose a new youth allowance. He admits some future claimants “will not get what they would get today”.

On this page(4)
Some young people may no longer be entitled to their current benefits, after Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said a “complete reset” of the system is needed to support the 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, work or training.
What Is the Milburn Review?
The number of so-called NEETs passed one million earlier this year. A “landmark review” of the issue by Alan Milburn is due to be published on Tuesday, 17 November and is widely expected to put forward sweeping changes. The former Labour health secretary was commissioned to carry out the review after fears of a backbench rebellion led the government to scale back some of its welfare proposals.
Milburn has indicated that his proposals would mean less financial help for young people if they are implemented. They would be moved away from health-related benefits and onto a new “youth allowance” paid at the standard Universal Credit rate.
Asked whether some people should lose the support they currently receive, he told the BBC’s Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg: “There will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today. When people come up for reassessment, they go on to a new system but, as I say, people are reassessed today under the current system.”
What Is the Opportunity Guarantee?
Milburn argues that young people deserve a “legal guarantee” of work, training or employment support. He said the government will “avoid the elephant trap” of young people taking legal action if no opportunities were available. “We are going to have a duty on Government to provide opportunities. We’re calling it the opportunity guarantee, so there should be a guarantee for a young person because at the moment the only guarantee they’ve got is to a very simple thing, to get a benefit.”
McFadden said ministers must pursue reform not “in spite of being Labour people” but “because we are Labour people”, following concerns over whether the government can win the support of its own MPs. He said: “If you’re 20 right now and you sign on to long-term sickness benefits, you’ve got more chance of marking your 30th birthday and still being on them than having a steady job in between.”
What Has Andy Burnham Said?
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has described the politically sensitive report as a “watershed” moment, but has not committed to accepting all of its recommendations. When questioned about the large upfront investment required, the Prime Minister insisted that the reforms would not need “more money” but rather “spending differently” within government.
How Have the Conservatives Responded?
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said a legal entitlement “might sound a nice thing to do” but “doesn’t make sense”. She cautiously backed other parts of Milburn’s approach, saying his focus on moving away from “handing out cash for relatively mild conditions” and towards employment support was “the right direction of travel”.
She told Sky: “We think he should do it for all ages, not just under 25. You should not have a different system for a 24-year-old and a 26-year-old.”
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the Milburn review?
- It is a landmark review by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn into the number of young people not in education, work or training, due to be published on Tuesday, 17 November.
- How could benefits for young people change?
- Young people would be moved away from health-related benefits onto a new youth allowance paid at the standard Universal Credit rate, and Milburn admits some future claimants will not get what they would get today.
- What is the opportunity guarantee?
- It is a proposed duty on government to provide young people with work, training or employment support, rather than only the guarantee of a benefit.