Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026
Sport

Winning Is Not Enough for Manchester City to Move On From This Crisis

Jonathan Wilson argues that football's familiar language of resilience and togetherness cannot capture the scale of what City are facing after the guilty verdict

RC
Ryan Connolly
2 min read
Manchester City players maintain focus amid financial panel verdict reports

Can City just keep winning their way through this?

That is the question at the heart of Jonathan Wilson's column for the Guardian, written after Manchester City's commanding 3-0 win at Liverpool on Sunday 11 October. The answer, he argues, is no.

Erling Haaland struck the usual notes after the match. "It was tough," he said. "It was hard but we showed amazing character from back to front. So proud of everyone. Important to stay strong mentally, stick together and do what you can do something about, and the thing we can do something about is to play good football and fight together. That's the only thing we can do."

Strip away the context, Wilson writes, and Haaland could be talking about an injury crisis or the loss of a manager. The tropes are familiar: it was hard, we stuck together, we prevailed. But this is not a normal football crisis. This is about the club being found guilty of what Wilson calls "the greatest act of sustained cheating in the history of English football."

What do the numbers actually show?

Wilson points out that during the nine years under investigation, City's net transfer spending (before wages) was over £1.2bn, roughly 50% more than any other Premier League club. That spending delivered six league titles in seven years, making City the most dominant side English football has ever known, and precisely the argument for why spending controls exist in the first place.

He dismisses the defence that City only spent what others did under stricter controls: "not merely irrelevant but entirely bogus."

What can the players actually do?

Enzo Maresca told his squad to block out the noise. "Guys, the noise will always be there so it's about how we learn to deal with the noise and it's our duty to make our noise," the City manager said. "Our noise is to win games in the way we did today and to be happy."

Wilson acknowledges the absurdity of the position players and managers are in. None of this is Haaland's fault. He is a footballer doing his job while the executives responsible "lurk away from public scrutiny." But winning matches, Wilson argues, does not resolve anything.

Nobody knows whether the three points claimed at Anfield will still be City's by Christmas. Nobody knows what division they will be playing in next season. Nobody knows how severe the sanction could be.

"What this is emphatically not," Wilson concludes, "is just another football crisis from which City can move on by winning football matches. This is a crisis unlike anything English football has ever known, and it is one with which football's language is struggling to cope."

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the score in the Manchester City vs Liverpool match?
Manchester City defeated Liverpool 3-0 at Anfield on Sunday.
What did Erling Haaland say after the match?
Haaland praised the team's character and mental strength, emphasising the importance of sticking together and focusing on playing good football.
What is the status of the financial charges against Manchester City?
According to The Guardian, an independent panel has found the club guilty of financial breaches. Manchester City maintain their innocence and have appealed the decision.